What Is Stonewalling?

Have you ever been in a relationship where your partner shuts down during a discussion or argument? This behavior is known as stonewalling and it can have a devastating impact on relationships. In this blog, we will explore what stonewalling is, why people do it, and how it affects relationships.

We will also discuss the connection between stonewalling and emotional abuse. But don’t worry, we won’t leave you hanging- we’ll provide you with some tips on how to deal with stonewalling if you’re experiencing it in your relationship. So, let’s dive into the topic of stonewalling and learn how to overcome this obstacle in our relationships.

What is Stonewalling in a Relationship?

Stonewalling is a relationship behavior where one partner withdraws from communication during conflict, often as a defense mechanism. If left unaddressed, it can cause emotional harm and damage the relationship. Couples therapy can help improve communication skills and address stonewalling.

Understanding the Impact on Partners

When a person shuts down and withdraws from communication during a conflict rather than engaging with their partner to resolve it, it’s called stonewalling. This form of communication is often utilized as a defense mechanism to safeguard against feeling overwhelmed or attacked. However, when left unaddressed, stonewalling can have serious consequences for the emotional well-being of both partners and the relationship itself. Seeking professional help such as couples therapy or counseling can be an effective way to address this issue and improve communication for the benefit of both partners.

Recognizing the Signs of Stonewalling

Recognizing signs of stonewalling in a relationship involves keeping an eye out for certain behaviors that indicate a withdrawal from communication. Such behaviors include shutting down emotionally, refusing to engage in conversation even when prompted, and avoiding eye contact or physical touch. In some cases, a person may exhibit body language that suggests discomfort or a lack of interest in the conversation. It is essential to address stonewalling as it can cause emotional abuse and damage the relationship if left unaddressed. Seeking couples counseling is the best way to work on this challenging behavior while improving your overall communication skills.

Why Do People Stonewall?

Stonewalling can occur as a defense mechanism to avoid conflict or control the situation. It may also be related to past trauma or attachment styles. Communication and therapy can help address underlying issues and reduce stonewalling behavior, which can damage relationships.

The Psychology of Stonewalling

Stonewalling is an unintentional or intentional form of emotional abuse that happens when one person withdraws and shuts down emotionally during a conversation or argument. It is a learned defense mechanism that leads to discomfort, frustration, and resentment for the stonewalled partner. Symptoms include silence, refusal to communicate during conflict, lack of eye contact, closed body language, and emotional wall. Stonewalling affects mental health, communication, intimacy, and overall wellness in romantic relationships. The best thing you can do if your partner stonewalls you is to practice self-soothing in a healthy way. Seeking couples counseling with Gottman-certified therapists who specialize in the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse is also recommended.

The Role of Resentment in Stonewalling

When someone is feeling resentful in a relationship, it often leads to stonewalling behavior. This can happen intentionally as a form of emotional abuse or manipulation by the stonewaller or unintentionally when they shut down without realizing it. Either way, it’s crucial to address the root cause of resentment through communication and empathy. Mental health professionals recommend couples counseling for those who find themselves on either end of this damaging behavior. Silence can feel like a silent treatment for the person receiving it and can cause discomfort or gaslighting if left unaddressed. Therefore addressing this issue should be given priority for the wellness and happiness of both parties.

How Does Stonewalling Affect Relationships?

Stonewalling involves emotionally shutting down and withdrawing from a conversation or interaction, which can harm relationships by impeding communication and conflict resolution. It causes feelings of isolation, rejection, and frustration in the partner who feels shut out. The behavior can lead to resentment over time and undermine trust and intimacy in a relationship.

The Effects on Communication and Intimacy

When one partner shuts down during a disagreement or discussion, it can be difficult for the other partner to know how to proceed. This form of emotional abuse, known as stonewalling, has a devastating effect on relationships. The person stonewalling may not realize that their lack of response and eye contact is affecting their partner’s well-being, but it creates feelings of isolation and frustration in the receiving end of stonewalling. In fact, John Gottman’s research shows that when one partner shuts down, both partners experience an increase in heart rate and arousal.

Stonewalling can take different forms – intentional or unintentional stonewalling may occur in the middle of a conversation or even after an argument is over. For some people, especially those who grew up with parents who used this tactic as a defense mechanism or form of emotional abuse like gaslighting or manipulation, stonewalling may seem like the best thing to do when they feel discomfort. Couples counseling or therapy with a mental health professional trained in clinical psychology or psychiatry can help couples learn healthy ways to self-soothe while still maintaining emotional intimacy and affection within romantic relationships.

The Connection between Stonewalling and Self-Soothing

When a person stonewalls their partner during a conversation or interaction, they withdraw emotionally and create feelings of discomfort, neglect, and frustration. This unintentional form of emotional abuse can erode trust and intimacy in romantic relationships over time. To resolve this issue, it’s best to seek professional help such as couples therapy or counseling to address the underlying issues causing unintentional stonewalling behavior. By learning healthy ways to self-soothe during disagreements rather than shutting down completely, both partners can improve their emotional intimacy. Gottman’s research has shown that even unintentional stonewalling can lead to chronic stonewalling if left unchecked. Therefore seeking professional help is the best thing one can do for their mental health wellness.

Is Stonewalling Considered Emotional Abuse?

Stonewalling, the act of refusing to communicate or resolve conflict, is indeed a form of emotional abuse. It can cause feelings of frustration and isolation in relationships. If you or someone you know has experienced stonewalling or other types of emotional abuse, seeking professional help is recommended.

The Relationship between Stonewalling and Abuse

Emotional abuse in relationships can manifest in different forms such as stonewalling. The stonewaller shuts down communication by refusing to engage in conversation or making eye contact while invalidating their partner’s emotions. By doing so, they cause discomfort and anxiety leading to chronic stress on the receiving end of stonewalling. This psychological behavior can erode intimacy and empathy between partners leading to resentment between them. Gottman’s research shows that couples counseling can help address stonewalling behavior by improving communication and addressing underlying issues leading to a healthy relationship.

Can Stonewalling Be Resolved?

Stonewalling can be resolved through effective communication and therapy. Identifying the root cause is crucial, and both parties must be willing to listen and communicate. Seeking professional help from a therapist or counselor can greatly improve the chances of resolving stonewalling in a relationship.

Gottman’s Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse in Relationships

Gottman’s Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse in Relationships are negative communication patterns that can harm romantic relationships. Clinical psychology expert John Gottman identified these horsemen as criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling. Stonewalling is when one partner shuts down during an argument or conversation due to feeling overwhelmed or emotionally flooded. This can result in the other partner feeling dismissed and invalidated. Stonewalling is also considered a form of emotional abuse that can lead to feelings of isolation and frustration in a relationship. Couples therapy or counseling can help resolve unintentional or intentional stonewalling by identifying its root cause and improving communication skills between partners.

What Can You Do If Your Partner Stonewalls You?

Stonewalling can be resolved through communication and counseling if both parties are willing to work towards a resolution. The stonewaller must acknowledge their behavior’s impact on the relationship, and both parties should improve communication and find healthier ways to express emotions.

What’s the antidote to stonewalling?

Stonewalling can be overcome through communication and effort, possibly with the assistance of a therapist. Both partners must recognize the negative impact of the behavior on their relationship. Developing active listening skills and finding healthy ways to express emotions can help resolve stonewalling.

How can stonewalling be avoided in relationships?

Stonewalling is a behavior in which one partner in a relationship withdraws or shuts down emotionally during an argument or conflict. This can be incredibly frustrating for the other partner and can escalate the issue at hand. Here are some tips for avoiding stonewalling in relationships:

1. Practice active listening: Make sure you are actively listening to your partner’s concerns, even if you disagree with them. This means not interrupting, making eye contact, and repeating back what your partner has said to validate their feelings.

2. Take breaks when needed: Sometimes conflicts can become overwhelming, and taking a break can be necessary to calm down and reflect. Agree on a time limit for the break, and come back to the conversation when you are both feeling more composed.

3. Use “I” statements: Avoid accusing or blaming language and instead use “I” statements to express how you feel. For example, “I feel hurt when you ignore me during an argument.”

4. Find common ground: Look for areas where you and your partner can agree and build from there. This can help to create a more positive and collaborative atmosphere for problem-solving.

5. Seek professional help: If stonewalling is a persistent issue in your relationship, it may be helpful to seek the guidance of a therapist or counselor. They can provide you with tools and strategies to communicate more effectively and work through conflicts in a healthy manner.

Why is stonewalling an unhealthy communication style?

Stonewalling is an unhealthy communication style because it involves shutting down and withdrawing from communication with the other person. This can leave the other person feeling ignored, dismissed, or frustrated, causing a breakdown in communication and potentially damaging the relationship. Stonewalling can also prevent issues from being resolved, as the person who is stonewalling is refusing to engage in conversation or address the problem at hand. Overall, stonewalling can lead to feelings of emotional distance and disconnection, which can have negative impacts on both individuals involved in the communication. It is important to address stonewalling behavior and work towards more open and constructive communication styles for healthy relationships.

What are the consequences of stonewalling?

Stonewalling, which refers to the act of refusing to communicate or cooperate with someone, can have serious consequences on both personal and professional relationships. At a personal level, stonewalling can lead to feelings of frustration, anger, and resentment, as it makes it impossible for individuals to resolve conflicts or reach a mutual understanding. In romantic relationships, stonewalling can be particularly damaging, as it often leads to emotional disconnection and a breakdown in intimacy.

In a professional context, stonewalling can cause serious problems within a team or organization. When individuals refuse to communicate or share information, it can lead to misunderstandings, delays, and even project failures. Teams that rely on open communication and collaboration are much more likely to succeed than those where stonewalling is prevalent.

Moreover, stonewalling can also have significant psychological effects, both on the person doing the stonewalling and on the person on the receiving end. People who use stonewalling as a defense mechanism are often trying to protect themselves from perceived threats, but in doing so, they may be inadvertently pushing away the people around them. The person on the receiving end of stonewalling may experience feelings of rejection, helplessness, and despair, which can be very damaging to their mental health.

In conclusion, stonewalling is a harmful behavior that can have serious consequences on both personal and professional relationships. It is essential to recognize the signs of stonewalling and take action. Stonewalling is a toxic behavior that can poison relationships both at home and in the workplace. It is important to address stonewalling behavior and work towards more open and constructive communication styles to avoid the negative impacts it can have on both individuals involved in the communication. By recognizing the signs of stonewalling and taking action, we can help cultivate healthy relationships and build successful teams. Let’s make a commitment to open and honest communication, and say goodbye to stonewalling for good!

What can you do to stop stonewalling in a conversation?

Stonewalling in a conversation can be frustrating and can prevent productive communication. Here are some steps you can take to stop stonewalling in a conversation:

1. Acknowledge the behavior: If you notice that the other person is stonewalling, acknowledge it and express your concern. For example, you can say, “I’ve noticed that you’re not responding to what I’m saying. Can we talk about what’s going on?”

2. Use “I” statements: Use “I” statements instead of accusatory “you” statements. For example, you can say, “I feel like you’re not listening to me” instead of “You never listen to me.”

3. Take a break: Sometimes, taking a break from the conversation can be helpful. You can suggest taking a break and coming back to the conversation later.

4. Try active listening: Active listening involves listening to the other person without interrupting and reflecting back what they’ve said. This can help create a more productive conversation.

5. Seek professional help: If stonewalling is a persistent issue in your conversations, seeking professional help from a therapist or counselor can be beneficial. They can help you and the other person work through communication issues and develop healthy communication habits.

What are the long-term effects of stonewalling on relationships?

Stonewalling can have serious long-term effects on a relationship. When one partner consistently withdraws, avoids communication, and shuts down emotionally, it can lead to a breakdown in communication, emotional distance, and even the eventual breakdown of the relationship.

Over time, stonewalling can erode trust, intimacy, and connection between partners. The partner who feels stonewalled may begin to feel rejected, unimportant, or unloved. They may also start to feel resentful, angry, or frustrated by their partner’s lack of engagement. This can lead to a cycle of negative emotions and behaviors that can be difficult to break.

In addition to damaging the relationship with a partner, stonewalling can also have negative effects on one’s own mental and emotional health. It can lead to feelings of loneliness, depression, anxiety, and stress, as well as physical health problems such as high blood pressure and heart disease.

To avoid these negative long-term effects, it’s important to recognize the signs of stonewalling and address the issue as soon as possible. This may involve seeking the help of a therapist or counselor, practicing better communication skills, and working on building trust and intimacy in the relationship. By taking active steps to address stonewalling, partners can strengthen their relationship and prevent long-term damage.

How can you repair a relationship after stonewalling has occurred?

Stonewalling, which is a common defense mechanism in relationships, can be a significant hurdle to overcome when trying to repair a relationship. However, there are some steps you can take to begin repairing the relationship after stonewalling has occurred:

1. Take responsibility: Start by taking responsibility for your actions. Acknowledge that stonewalling is a hurtful behavior and that you played a role in causing harm to your relationship.

2. Communicate openly: Communication is crucial in any relationship. Make an effort to communicate openly and honestly with your partner. Try to identify the reasons behind your stonewalling and share them with your partner.

3. Listen actively: Listen to your partner’s concerns and feelings. Put yourself in their shoes and try to understand their perspective without being defensive.

4. Show empathy: Express empathy for your partner’s feelings and try to validate their emotions. This can help your partner to feel heard and understood.

5. Seek professional help: Consider seeking professional help if you are struggling to repair your relationship after stonewalling. A therapist can help you to identify the underlying causes of your stonewalling and provide tools and strategies for improving communication and resolving conflict.

Remember that repairing a relationship after stonewalling takes time and effort. It requires a willingness to be vulnerable, to listen actively, and to work together to rebuild trust and intimacy.

How can you recognize when someone is stonewalling?

Stonewalling is a behavior where a person refuses to engage in a conversation or communication, often by avoiding eye contact, giving monosyllabic responses, or completely ignoring the other person. It can be challenging to recognize when someone is stonewalling, but some signs can help identify the behavior.

One sign of stonewalling is a lack of responsiveness or interest in the conversation. The person may not acknowledge the other person’s statements or questions, offer irrelevant responses, or provide no reaction at all. They may also give vague or non-committal answers, such as “I don’t know” or “I don’t care.”

Another sign of stonewalling is physical avoidance. The person may turn away from the other person, cross their arms, or shift their body away from the conversation. They may also appear distracted, such as checking their phone or looking around the room.

Finally, stonewalling often involves emotional distance. The person may seem cold, resentful, or defensive, and avoid talking about their feelings or thoughts. They may also become angry or defensive if the other person persists in trying to communicate with them.

Overall, stonewalling is a behavior that can be challenging to recognize, but it often involves a lack of engagement, avoidance, and emotional distance. If you suspect someone is stonewalling, it may be helpful to address the behavior directly and try to find a way to communicate effectively.

Conclusion

Stonewalling is a serious issue that can lead to the breakdown of relationships. It can be caused by various reasons, including resentment, fear, and anxiety. Stonewalling can have significant effects on communication and intimacy in relationships, leading to emotional abuse. However, it is possible to resolve stonewalling through open communication, understanding the four horsemen of apocalypse in relationships, and seeking professional help. Our experts are here to guide you through this challenging time. If you or someone you know is struggling with stonewalling in their relationship, please get in touch with us today for a consultation.

How can our expert divorce solicitors help you?

Our expert divorce solicitors can help you with a range of legal issues:

• Prenuptial agreements
• Cohabitation agreements
• Post civil partnership agreements
• Divorce
• Domestic violence and harassment
• Child maintenance
• Child contact arrangements
• Divorce financial provisions

Contact our expert divorce solicitors for advice

For more information call our divorce solicitors on 0845 862 5001 or email mail@austinkemp.co.uk.

• Our expert divorce solicitors offer a nationwide service. We have client meeting office facilities available, in order to have face-to-face client meetings / conferences as and when required in our:
• Leeds Office: St Andrew House, The Headrow, Leeds, LS1 5JW
• Sheffield Office: Pinfold Street, The Balance, Sheffield, S1 2GU
• Manchester Office: King Street, Manchester, M2 4PD
• Wakefield Office: Market Walk, Wakefield, WF1 1QR
• Canary Wharf Office: 25 Canada Square, Canary Wharf, London, E14 5LB
• London Office: Berkeley Square House, Mayfair, London, W1J 6BD
• Please contact us for more details.

More helpful insights from legal experts

• How do you work out divorce fees?
• How to make the divorce process cost as little as possible
• How to protect finances during a divorce
• No-fault divorce UK – Guide
• What is a financial order in a divorce?
• Forensic accounting in divorce
• How long does a divorce take?
• What is the divorce process?
• When is decree absolute granted in a divorce?
• Limited companies and divorce
• How to Protect Your Assets When Divorcing in the UK
• Financial Agreement Divorce: How to Ensure a Fair Settlement
• High Net Worth Divorce Solicitors: Protecting Your Assets During Divorce
• Fair Divorce Settlement Examples for High Net Worth Individuals
• Forensic accountancy in divorce

For further information

Useful websites

• https://www.gov.uk/apply-for-divorce
• https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/form-d8-application-for-a-divorce-dissolution-or-to-apply-for-a-judicial-separation-order
• https://www.advicenow.org.uk/
• https://www.advicenow.org.uk/guides/survival-guide-pensions-divorce
• https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom