Get in touch

Could our fault-based divorce system leave you in a marriage you don’t want to be in?

A few weeks ago, a woman called Tini Owens took her case to the Supreme Court, in an attempt to finally get the divorce she has been fighting for over a number of years.

First, a little history of the case. After being refused a divorce by the family courts a few years ago, Mrs Owens had taken her case to the Court of Appeal, who ultimately upheld the court’s judgement, as her husband’s behaviour was not deemed “unreasonable enough”.


In what is a very unusual case, as the vast majority of divorces in England and Wales are not contested, Mr Owens reportedly does not want a divorce as he feels that they still have “few years” left to enjoy.


What are the grounds for divorce?


In England and Wales, the person who starts the divorce proceedings must prove that the marriage has irretrievably broken down, by establishing either adultery, unreasonable behaviour, desertion, 2 years separation with consent from the other party or 5 years separation with no consent required.


This means that, in reality, if a couple do not want to place blame on the other party and there is no consent, they must wait until they have been separated for 5 years before they can get a divorce.

fault-based divorce


Tini Owens petitioned for divorce based on “unreasonable behaviour”


According to the Office for National Statistics, the most common grounds for divorce is “unreasonable behaviour”.


Mrs Owens cited “unreasonable behaviour” when petitioning for divorce. Mr Owens decided to defend the divorce.


In order for a divorce to be granted, the courts have to be satisfied that the “respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent.”


Time for no-fault divorce?


Whilst relatively unusual in the 21st century, the case of Tini Owens has served to highlight what many people believe is an outdated system, which results in additional animosity and hurt between divorcing couples, during what are already very difficult, emotional times.


Many argue that a fault-based divorce system, where a woman is forced to remain in a marriage that she very clearly does not want to be in, is completely out of place in modern times and needs urgent reform, so that cases such as this do not occur again.


According to a survey by Resolution, who called the current system “outdated, unfair, and unnecessary”, 80% of professionals questioned believed that the introduction of a no-fault divorce would make it more likely for separated couples to reach an agreement out of court. This can only be a good thing.


“…ridiculous that Mrs Owens has to come to the highest court in the land in order to escape a loveless marriage”


Nigel Shepherd, immediate past Chair of Resolution said that it was “ridiculous that Mrs Owens has to come to the highest court in the land in order to escape a loveless marriage”.


A ruling is expected by the Supreme Court on the Tini Owens case later this year. While Mrs Owens may ultimately get the divorce she so obviously wants (taking her case to the Court of Appeal and then to the Supreme Court will undoubtedly have been difficult for her), any decision made by the Supreme Court will only be based on existing statute.


Whether the government will have the time to make what many believe are very important changes to divorce law in England and Wales, whilst trying to handle the UK’s divorce from the EU, remains to be seen.


Do you need help with advice on finances during divorce


Our expert divorce and family law solicitors can help you with a range of legal issues, including:


Contact our expert divorce solicitors for advice on divorce


For more information on your divorce options, call our divorce solicitors on 0845 862 5001 or


Our expert divorce and family law solicitors offer a nationwide service. We have client meeting office facilities available, in order to have face-to-face client meetings / conferences as and when required in:

Leeds Office: St Andrew House, The Headrow, Leeds, LS1 5JW

Wakefield Office: Market Walk, Wakefield, WF1 1QR

Halifax Office: Old Lane, Halifax, HX3 5WP

Huddersfield Office: Northumberland Street Huddersfield, HD1 1RL

Coventry Office: Warwick Road, Coventry, CV1 2DY

Canary Wharf Office: 25 Canada Square, Canary Wharf, London, E14 5LB

Please contact us for more details.

Was this article helpful?

19th June 2018

Chess Piece

Make the first move

Find out how we can help you, call us on
0333 311 0925 or email us today.

Contact Us
Back up to top Back to Top